If you can’t stand Tim Tebow, here’s the good news: This will be the last Tebow-related piece I write until at least August, barring some unforeseen incident involving a trade or the Rapture.
The bad news is that it’s going to be another long one.
The Denver Broncos’ improbable run ended Saturday at the hands of a Patriots team that dominated Denver in every phase of the game. So, too, ends Tim Tebow’s storied season, but not without leaving several questions needing to be revisited sometime in 2012.
1. By what specific set of criteria, if one exists, may Tebow satisfy his critics?
Tim Tebow’s harshest critics—just like his strongest supporters—remain resolute in their opinions despite any evidence to the contrary. But how many of his detractors can honestly say that he didn’t exceed the level of success they anticipated? Recall that Denver had gone 5-16 in its previous 21 games before Tebow got the starting job for good in Week Seven of 2011.
I would wager heavily that the critics would have gladly accepted the following proposition back in October: “If the Denver Broncos win the AFC West and then win a playoff game with Tim Tebow as their quarterback for that entire span, then we can rightfully call Tebow a successful and effective professional football player.”
Yet, many of those same people will now say things ranging from “Tebow will never start another game in the NFL” to “Tebow is still the worst quarterback in the league.”
Tebow’s future seems uncertain at best (see below), but his critics have been very consistent in following up each defeat with proclamations that they’ve been definitively proven right in their assertion that he has no future in the NFL. They’ve met his successes with temporary silence and eager anticipation of his next stumble. I would like for someone on that side of the argument to list a set of criteria that Tebow could meet that would “prove” him to be a “success.”
That way, if Tebow wins ten games next season and throws for 3,000 yards, or, say, wins a couple of Super Bowls down the road (which I personally think would be very unlikely), these journalists won’t have to bother embarrassing themselves any further by continuing to move the rhetorical goal line such that Tebow could never cross it.
Continue reading →
Quick Thoughts on the Rumble
I’m trying my best to keep this charmingly eclectic website from morphing into an all-wrestling blog, but I feel compelled to discuss a few things that happened last night after spending so much time in fevered anticipation of same. I will preface this by making two points.
First, I like Sheamus. I really do. I thought him winning the WWE Title in his first year in the company was great, and the creative team executed that angle superbly. I think he’s a main-event-level star.
However . . . the one thing I can’t abide is a breakdown in narrative integrity. Poor storytelling. That’s what happened last night.
Continue reading →
Share this: