SitCombat 3/1/12

The Office has hit an unexpected stride with a bifurcated workforce.  The NBC demographic powerhouse has won two consecutive weeks despite the fact that half of the employees of the titular place of business have been in Tallahassee.  The show even managed to assuage my fears of a turn for the soap-y by nailing an A-minus last week in an episode that incorporated a lot of personal relationship storylines.

Meanwhile, 30 Rock has been stumbling just a bit.  These certainly haven’t been bad shows by any means.  Just not good enough to topple Archer and the Office.  Even shows a half-notch below the lofty standards set by what has been the best comedy on television over the last five years still make for great TV more weeks than not.

Archer hasn’t won recently, but the wacky cartoon comedy always seems to be lurking. Will this be the week that ISIS gets back on top?  Let’s find out.  This was SitCombat for March 1, 2012:

30 Rock (NBC) – “Alexis Goodlooking and the Case of the Missing Whiskey”

Tonight’s Episode: Frank convinces his mom that he’s dating Liz, Jack tries to mentor Kenneth in the ways of business, and Jenna and Tracy use Jenna’s experience from a crime drama pilot to solve a workplace mystery.

Good Stuff: Kenneth’s dad is D. B. Cooper . . . “Or some black…-hearted individual. Probably white” . . . “And I should know…my uncle was a cop…in a porno” . . . “Mine was called ‘Goodlooking,’ I played Alexis Goodlooking, who was also good-looking, and my special ability was being good at looking for clues” . . . “I just had an emergency meeting with Legal, and we can no longer use the words ‘hit,’ ‘great show,’ ‘fun,’ or ‘broadcast television.’” . . . “Kenneth—a word?” “Balloon!” . . . “Exactly! ‘Paranoid,’ from the Greek ‘para,’ meaning ‘beside,’ and ‘noid,’ which is some sort of a, uh…pizza demon!” . . . “But I never crushed anyone. Except accused witches” . . . “If you think of anything, use this phone as a reminder to call us. I may not pick up, because I lost my phone JUST NOW” . . . Kenneth and Bradley shouting down Roy the Asian when he points out that the network needs more Asian actors on its shows . . . “I hate to say ‘toldja’…because it reminds me of my one-night stand with Nikki Finke” . . . “…for the good of company…and country.” “My two favorite kinds of music!” . . . Tracy thinking the #1 rule of being on the force is “Don’t fall in love with your car” . . . “QUIET!  I DO THE TALKING!” . . . Warren’s life after being “taken down” . . . Jack’s sofa is made out of Seabiscuit . . . “Because we have you dead to rights, you black bastard!” . . . “The sight of these people, plus the crayons I ate earlier…make me sick” . . . “Forget it, Tracy.  It’s Mid-town” . . . “I get all MY news from the radio in Grand Theft Auto” . . . Lynn’s uncreative tattoo . . . Johnny Carson’s monologue joke about Lynn . . . Pete’sGuitar Man . . . “Now, I don’t know nothin’ ‘bout no lit-rature o’ history, but I tell you what I DO know: This movie was written by white nerds”

Non-good Stuff: Unless they could have found a way to shoehorn in Grizz and Dot Com (or Cerie), I don’t think this episode could have gotten any better.

Line of the Night (there were about ten, but I’ll pick one):

LIZ (to Frank): I can’t be your girlfriend because I’m not an old pedophile.
LYNN (from under a desk): We prefer the term “adultophobe.”

Overall: Joke-for-joke, this is as good as any episode of 30 Rock I can remember, and that’s saying a lot.  All three storylines worked, and I think one of the reasons is that the pairing of the two main characters for each (Liz/Frank, Kenneth/Jack, Jenna/Tracy) was a good fit.  The best way I can sum up this episode is as follows: 30 Rock is known for the frenetic pace of bits and lines in the cold open and, often, the beginning of the first act.  This episode somehow kept up that insane pace for an entire show.  Best episode of the season so far, and one of the best ever in the show’s run.  As a sidebar, I wonder if they’re setting up Kenneth to take Jack’s place if and when Alec Baldwin leaves the show.  We seem to be headed in that direction.

GRADE: A-plus

The Office (NBC) – “Test the Store”

Tonight’s Episode: The Sabre test store opens, and Andy gets beaten up(?) by a fifth-grader(?!?).

Good Stuff: Erin pretending to be a hipster . . . Dwight’s largely accurate rant on bloggers . . . “Schrute’s out to get me, but I’m playing the long game. As soon as he messes up, I swoop in like a sexual predator” . . . I liked the meta-joke about Jim possibly pretending to be Chuck . . . “Tell your great-grandson to bring his kid by!” . . . Rape flute . . . “Fatty Gruesome” . . . It’s hard to believe I originally didn’t like Ryan’s character. What a difference a few seasons can make. He gets me every time” . . . “‘FIX’ MEANS YOU HATE IT!” . . . Andy’s fake deep voice . . . Stanley keeping a piece of pizza in his pyramid pouch . . . Georgia Engel sighting . . . “Go get into Ryan’s costume, and check out his notes” . . . “…Gender. There are no rules anymore” . . . The picture used with “the future” was the space shuttle . . . Bonus: No Gabe!

Non-good Stuff: Andy getting beaten up by a gang of little girls on bikes was dumb . . . Also, I don’t think a shiner like that is going to form during the two minutes it takes to get from the parking lot to the office . . . The ending seemed strangely abrupt . . . “Sign-spinner” is a job at which I wouldn’t WANT to get good.

Line of the Night: “How about we wait ‘til next year when YOU have YOUR kid?” – Pam, to the fifth-grade female bully.

Overall: The problem with the Scranton story was that they strayed too far away from reality, even for a zany sitcom.  There’s a fine line between “wacky” (which is fine) and “implausible,” which is what happened with the home plot.  It felt like they had to workvery hard to get to a “Toby teaches self-defense in the office” bit.  The Scranton stuff was fine once we got there, but getting there was awkward.  The away plot, on the other hand, was strong once again.  Dwight getting the VP gig might set the stage for more changes to the show.  Or, perhaps more likely, a tease that leads to a return to the status quo by the end of the year, with Packer staying in Tallahassee.  Another good effort, although there’s been a mild drop-off the last couple of weeks.

GRADE: B-plus

Archer (FX) – “Crossing Over”

Tonight’s Episode: Archer and Pam start a secret affair, while Jakov defects with Barry in pursuit.

Good Stuff: “You could skip a step and just feed me some vomit” . . . “And let me be the first to welcome you back into the dating pool…and/or my hot tub” . . . “Prep School Lacrosse” . . . “Sometimes?” (obvious joke, but I loved it) . . . The other characters actually forgetting that Mallory is in a relationship with Burt Reynolds . . . Barry as the head of the KGB . . . “Et me, buddy” . . . Archer’s appearance upon returning from the bathroom . . . “ORIENTALS!  DUH!” . . . “Nice one, other Barry” . . . “…and fif…FORty thousand bucks in a floor safe” . . . “It has to be your place, because mine reeks of ocelot piss” “I have…no response to that” . . . The running answering message bit is growing on me . . . Barry is a great evil character . . . “…or Richie Havens!” . . . “Come on, you were pushin’ rope!”

Non-good Stuff: Cyrill is just terrible sometimes . . . I feel like they work in external car shots now just to show off the budget, but it still looks a little weird and out-of-place with the rest of the animation style used by the show

Line of the Night: “You make me sound like some kind of chupacabra . . . but for d**ks.” – Pam, accurately describing her relations with Archer.

Overall: Great episode.  The Pam/Archer thing was set up in such a way that it made sense, and the return of Barry was a nice surprise.  Barry is the perfect foil for Archer, and his involvement usually raises the level of the show.  This was no exception.  There wasn’t much not to like.  Everyone had some good moments (except Cyrill) and Barry and Pam stole the show at various points.  This looks like the beginning of a multi-episode arc that will have Archer facing off against Barry once again (with predictable, but hilarious results), and possibly getting to the bottom of his mysterious parentage.


Final Thoughts: Tough break for Archer this week.  This was an episode that was probably one of the two best this year, but it went up against THE best 30 Rock episode of the season in my estimation.  The Office was also good, but took the imaginary bronze despite a B-plus effort.  This was one of those weeks when everybody won, because even the third-place show was quite good.  30 Rock prevails on the strength of an episode that I believe is among the finest ever written.

WINNER: 30 Rock (new champion)

This entry was posted in Commentary, Reviews, Television and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.